SirRobyn0
Full Access Member
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2019
- Posts
- 6,755
- Reaction score
- 11,402
- Location
- In the woods in Western Washington
- First Name
- Rob
- Truck Year
- 1984
- Truck Model
- C20
- Engine Size
- 305
I've done the RPM calculations vs typical towing speed on the highway. 4.10's would allow me to be in a comfortable RPM speed in drive (I'd have to check my notes for specifics), for typical towing on the highway and still have a little bit more to go incase driving a little faster is a requirement (passing, traffic speed ect.). 4.56's would put right at the top of what I'd be comfortable with, and I'd probably be a the gas drinking stage. Going any faster would not be an option. Without using OD. Thanks.I ain't the requested expert, but about the only thing I can think of is that there's a band that's applied in 2nd and 4th gear that can slip under heavy torque loads. They make a band with more surface area and a larger servo that applies more clamping force. It was the 3-4 clutches that would cook if your engine didn't have enough huevos to hold 4th gear. The fluid flows slower through the cooler in OD, but that'd probably be mitigated at least somewhat with a shorter final drive... and cooled more efficiently with an external cooler.
I'd have to check my paperwork as to whether or not a wide band was installed when the transmission was rebuilt last fall. I live in the hills, and where there aren't hills there are mountain passes. I currently have the 3.41 gears for me I don't think 3.73 would be enough. It's 4.10's or 4.56's to decide between.Inattentive drivers, and the weezing underpowered engines of the day is the reason why they say not to tow in overdrive. As long as nothing slips in the trans, probably 80% of the heat created in the transmission comes from the torque converter. The transmission really doesnt care what gear it’s in, as long as it doesn’t slip or overheat.
The aftermarket does offer wide bands that span the entire width of the drum it’s wrapped around. There are also servos that provide more clamping force. There are 5 different servo sizes if I remember. TransGo includes different accumulator spring in their shift kits to tame the aggressive shifts of the larger servo.
I don’t think you can go wrong with 3.73 or 4.10. A big heavy truck hauling a trailer with an underpowered engine needs all the mechanical advantages it can get.
I think I've already decided on the 4.10's just because it was kind of the gold standard in 3/4 ton and 1 tons, and I don't want to murder empty highway MPG. But until I finally get around to it, I like to explore thoughts and opinions. Thanks.