I have no problems with flat tappet cams at all if you are on a budget , (they have worked great for years) , but I really like all of the mild hydraulic roller cam builds I have been around , (two of my own and several others) with no problems. So if you want to save money by all means run a flat tappet, I on the other hand , (if I had the cash) would go hydraulic roller.
Why , the problems associated with hydraulic rollers in the past have been sorted out for the most part, and as far as advantages , no need to break in cam , the lifters can be reused if you change cams , the open and close ramps are faster , giving you more torque and horsepower for any given grind , roller cams wear at a fraction of the rate as a flat tappet cams , and you can use any of the late model motor oils with no zinc additives.
My girls 78 square has a 350 that we built a while back , (that for 3 years was her daily driver), has a comp. 270hr cam with morel hydraulic roller lifters is up to 59,000 miles on the clock without a hiccup. A few of my buddies have mild roller set ups in their square's and they run hard, but I don't know the mileage they have on them.
So I am a roller cam fan, but I don't hate on flat tappets and I would never own anything for 200,000 mile's, (I get to bored with stuff to quick), I would either take it apart and build it or sell it for something else, except for my wifes 4runner, just about to hit the 300,000 club.
So my budget build,(to get the best power and economy for my buck) would be build around the vortec's with a flat tappet cam, but if I had a little extra cash on hand I would shoot for the roller , just me and what I have been around in the roller cam world.
Thanks for your detailed comments.
I am by no means against retro rollers.... I understand all the benefits.... I only wish I could trust them for high mileage reliability. Even 150K would be
acceptable.
I respect guys that are maybe to say, on the hobby side of their old truck fetish. But I'm even a bit more crazy because I do this out of necessity.
And to make matters worse, I'll admit I actually think these old engines and parts are better than anything new... and a fraction of the cost.
If you gave a 2019 fully loaded $100K truck I sorry but I would sell it and buy old junk.
And just to be clear, I'm referring to retro rollers, for the older blocks never designed for this. Also I am usually referring to BBs... because I have a few on the build now waiting for the shop to get finished, and I so wish I could trust the rollers! The hot rod and truck guys in my woods with roller experience are for the most part BB junkies. So I don't really have any reliable info with sb and rollers... but take note my machinist/builder and a tech from Lunati both
told me small blocks with retro rollers will out live BB rollers.. Maybe there's something to that, perhaps not opening the valves over 1/2" helps.
Oh I forgot Dave (Dave's not here...) my BB head porting guru... This guy always drives 600+ hp trucks and sometimes Corvettes. He likes 496s and rollers. he eventually switched to solid rollers (from hyd rollers...again, retro). Amazing dude, but also kinda like wtf... He used to build fancy furniture... like
formal dining room table and chairs that would sell for $150K in the US. He has some brain issue and needs to see a specialist in Pennsylvania. And he has to drive, he can't fly or get an aneurysm or three..
Sorry I digress.. But man can he ever port a set of 781...!
AND ONE LAST POINT about retro rollers that really picks MY ASS...
I build for propane. I like it... Hides the smell of my farts. My propane engines idle down to 500-550 rpm. They also rev up really quickly, like a 2 stroke!
Can you guess the potential problem for dem little needle bearings inside the rollers? Give you a hint... it has something to do with oil... or lack thereof..
Again this was something the Lunati tech told me.