I’ll go get some better angle photos to show. I don’t know the first thing about catalytic converters other than everyone steals them for some reason
If yours is bad, steal it yourself and bring it to scrap yard. your wallet would be thicker. (thats why they are stolen. 2 seconds and a saw zall and a bad moral/ethical decision later and youre holding money from someones vehicle.)
Ive seen a shop that sold someone a cat (unsuspecting older folks) and they clearly punched out the guts and then installed the body of it because there was no insides when the car died and a friend cut those off to quickly part some of its valuables. The thing has 3 and makes me wonder if they did that to the others(I wasnt around for those)
what we are saying is all true here, bex is just giving you the basic laydown of what a pragmatic environmentally and personally aware person would say.
ie, do you want to reduce exhaust smell or gas smells, help the environment, and already own a cat?
If then, do you own a cat which has not degraded badly or plugged or been damaged?
If then, do you want to keep it working right?
if then, mount it forward in the exhaust stream(as he pointed out) and that will help
if
not, then you would be best to scrap it and your choice to install one back into it (environmentally good, smells better, but costs $$. thats where he, or I, would then choose not to get one because of the prohibitive cost)
bex is proof that you dont have to be a hippie to make decisions best for the world, but also isnt a ghoul who would run without one to "stick it" to someone, presumably a caricature of someone online never met. I like to think a lot of people, truly, would be like this. As long as the personal burden or costs arent so much, we can make decisions that are good for everything.
however the pellet type comment is also a good one, if it was like those then its best to remove. iirrc those cats tended to be more circular than flat, but i could be thinking about a particular example rather than a rule.