Order the black one and dye it yourself.
First thing is to fit the new one to your truck ... THEY all say you may have to trim.
Second decide which paint / Dye you want to go with ..
SEM lots of Colors - Mine was Shadow Blue
USA -1 (ships paint within days - I know I have ordered over 12 cans of total of 81-87 Blue and 79-80 Mystic for my headliner trim)
LMC - I have never used but lots have.
Study up on how to repaint / dye.
I used all SEM Products.
SEM Soap
SEM Solve
SEM Vinyl Prep
Top Coat Paint of your choice ...
Plastic's take a different adhesive / activator (One for ABS Plastic and One for All other Plastics)
I changed out a 1983 Brown Pad to fit my 1985 Blue and it turned out near perfect.
Plenty of gloves.
Take your ole dash pad, and experiement with it maybe on the right hand side... Clean it, Clean it, Clean it, degrease it , use vinyl prep and then Light coats at first, followed by more light coats, followed by a nice flowing coat completely all around
I was nervous about doing mine, once I figured it out, I have repainted the entire interior.
A-Pillars upper and lower, B-Pillars, headliner trim pieces, dash pad, arm rests, console, kick panels, door panels, cargo panels,.
Watch You Tube videos, contact SEM Customer Support (they will visit with you on how to use their products)
I did buy a bumper stand / work stand off Amazon to hold the pad while I painted it ... as for the other pieces I bought a painters rack to suspend everything else while I painted to get both sides painted. Both of these items were being used at the body shop that painted my blazer so I figured they would work fine for me ..
Yes, it was expensive, but doing a full resotration on my part it was worth the investment.
Figure out what you need and go for it....
I have 100% faith you can tackle this and be proud of your finished product.