@DoubleDingo,
What parts outlet did you get the pumps from? Many years ago, early '90's, Auto Zone came under a couple of FBI indictments for carrying counterfeit parts. The Customs Dept. raided a couple warehouses in China that were full of boxes that looked exactly like factory parts boxes except for some graphics details you wouldn't notice at first unless you put two boxes side buy side and then you'd see where the Chinese almost duplicated the factory box but couldn't copy the real factory box and come under fraud charges to, so some minor changes were made to get them into the country.
I got a couple of those parts, water pumps. The seals would go out in a day or so, and the bearing went out in a few hours. I took the last pump back and got a refund and went across the street and got a good one from another parts place. Needless to say I don't ever buy parts from Auto Zone anymore. It seems to me that either the parts you got were just bad manufacturing quality control or they're counterfeit. These days and times with everything coming from China these parts wouldn't necessarily be counterfeit, they're just bad stuff made by China. And they don't care either. They know the company will get the money back by people buying good parts. It's all a racket!! China is getting paid by, say Auto Zone when they buy the parts being made there. China gets their money.