Mmm... I'm going to pick the BF Goodrich. My very opinionated father always drilled it in to me that if you were going to run RWL tires, they just had to be Radial T/A's, and everything else looked stupid. Having had different performance tires in the past, I can't really say that Radial T/A's do anything better or worse than the others, but I do think they are the better option as far as aesthetics go... I had some Goodyear Eagles on my 4th gen Firechicken, and liked them too.
As far as all terrain tires, I have some All Terrain T/A KO 32's on my truck that have done extremely well over the years... and are almost old enough to vote (15th and 17th week of 2001). Now, the truck did spend 6 years being used as a summer driver only, then 5 years in storage... but it was my year 'round driver until 2008, and has been again since 2019. While I don't thrash on the vehicle, and it sees a fair amount of highway use, I do use it for plenty of non-mall crawling things... hauling firewood, trailers, driving logging roads, unmaintained utility roads and the occasional railroad right of way. I do some night photography and explore abandoned buildings and ghost towns, have driven abandoned highways that are overgrown with vegetation and other crap, off road in horse pastures and the desert- you get the idea. Some of the stuff I frequently encounter are broken glass, chunks of scrap metal, construction debris, sharp rocks, cactus. The tires have held up to all of this, they're wearing very evenly (I honestly can't remember how many miles I have on them), and they're quiet and behave very well on the highway up to and above legal speeds. They even hang on better than they should when cornering at speed. Only fault I can come up with is that the treads tend to clog when you run into that super silty mud here in Arizona. And they have a little less bite than some of the others when faced with packed snow and ice near or above the freezing point.
With those experiences, I'ma have a hard time *not* buying All Terrain T/A's for my next set... if only I could wear out Bush era set that I've got now. I'm still not really keen on the KO2's sidewall lugs, though... I prefer the squarer profile of the old KO's.