Chances are they are OK. Unless they are pitted and even then, hell I'd run'em. So long as they aren't rusted up at the mating surface where they mount to the carrier to where they won't fit flush, a little rust isn't to hurt, and when they get used, submerged in gear oil, heated up a bit and being used I'd say that rust will get polished off. These ones I have even have a little rust on them where the gears were not submerged in oil and moisture from sweat got on the gears. So these may not even be any better than what you have.
If I wasn't so strapped on cash and trying to get whatever wil sale to sell, I'd give you a real good deal on these. So if you don't think you need them and they're probably not much better if any than yours, I'll list them on ebay for $100 like I did the 4.10's. If they don't sell in a couple weeks for that, then I'll hit you up for cheap deal.
The 4.10's I listed are surface rusted but I'm sure will clean up nice. Knowing they are almost new, when I set this 4.10 axle up with the Locker, I'm thinking of using this 3000 mile 4.10's with the Detroit Locker. If they don't sell for $100, then I'll use them and sell these used ones that's in it now for $75 or $50. I'm sure they're good too but why not have the newer lower mileage ones is my thankin !!! Then I won't feel so bad selling them so cheap.