Which dually - 8.1 vs pre-DEF 6.6?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Frankenchevy

Proverbs 16:18
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Posts
6,212
Reaction score
8,049
Location
USA
First Name
Jeremy
Truck Year
Square
Truck Model
CUCV
Engine Size
Small
Man, newer trucks are a pita. I’m half tempted to 12v swap my 1975 f350. It’s a super cab c&c and the rear end/frame look pretty stout to me.
 

Fastduramax

Supporting Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2022
Posts
308
Reaction score
506
Location
Uranus
First Name
Todd
Truck Year
1986
Truck Model
K10 Silverado
Engine Size
572
This is not even a debate, Dmax period end of any gas motor nonsense for towing... If you're going to tow anything heavier than a moped gassers SUCK anyone who tells you otherwise has never towed with a Dmax, Powerstroke or Cummins... Not to mention the vast tuning options with the Dmax, toss a 120hp non delete tune in it you wont even know that camper is behind you and that's from experience...
 

Grit dog

Full Access Member
Joined
May 18, 2020
Posts
7,539
Reaction score
13,447
Location
Auburn, Washington
First Name
Todd
Truck Year
1986, 1977
Truck Model
K20, C10
Engine Size
454, 350
If you’re not doing daily work with it, I’m not certain what you could possibly do with a dump trailer that your 3rd gen wouldn’t handle just fine. Don’t even need a dually unless you have a GN trailer and GN pin weights. Which the 3rd gen will still handle over 4k of pin weight easily.
If you are using it regularly and highway speeds/mountains, the 8.1 makes sense to me other than it’s cheaper than a diesel. Otherwise a LLY or LBZ will walk a 8.1 easily with a trailer. And a small tune and it’ll absolutely destroy the 8.1 but not the Allison.
Idk why the 8.1 is even a consideration unless infrequent use.
 

bucket

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Aug 3, 2010
Posts
31,464
Reaction score
31,311
Location
Usually not in Ohio
First Name
Andy
Truck Year
'77, '78, '79, '84, '88
Truck Model
K5 thru K30
Engine Size
350-454
This is not even a debate, Dmax period end of any gas motor nonsense for towing... If you're going to tow anything heavier than a moped gassers SUCK anyone who tells you otherwise has never towed with a Dmax, Powerstroke or Cummins... Not to mention the vast tuning options with the Dmax, toss a 120hp non delete tune in it you wont even know that camper is behind you and that's from experience...

It's a two way street here. Anyone with this opinion has little to no experience with an 8.1L. And I am someone that has DEFINITELY spend A LOT of time towing heavy loads with a Duramax. An 8.1 is not to be compared with a GM 6.0 or a Ford 6.2 or an Dodge whatever they put in those things.

I'm not at all saying that an 8.1 is superior, but it certainly is comparable and can hold a candle to a Duramax.
 

mxer147

83 K20, 350 vortec, 465, 208, 14/10, 4.10, 33s
Joined
Feb 8, 2023
Posts
693
Reaction score
2,581
Location
Colorado
First Name
Jack
Truck Year
1983
Truck Model
k20
Engine Size
350
Oh, I forgot to elaborate on the finicky Duramax PCM thing. I have no idea how many times I've been pulling a load down the highway and I've lost all power and had to pull off the side of the road, clear random fault codes, then get back along my way. It's always some stupid pidly little insignificant thing that the tuning isn't happy about, so it goes into some kind of limp mode that is basically undriveable. All the trucks too, not just one or two of them.
I’ve experienced limp mode on my 04, no codes but I am fairly certain it was related to filling the tank to the very top. One time died under significant load, other time it was after restarting.
 

bucket

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Aug 3, 2010
Posts
31,464
Reaction score
31,311
Location
Usually not in Ohio
First Name
Andy
Truck Year
'77, '78, '79, '84, '88
Truck Model
K5 thru K30
Engine Size
350-454
I’ve experienced limp mode on my 04, no codes but I am fairly certain it was related to filling the tank to the very top. One time died under significant load, other time it was after restarting.

It's always something completely stupid that sets them off. And usually when it goes into limp mode, it sets a few other codes because evidently the pcm is too stupid to figure out why other sensor readings are out of range (due to high throttle % and high speed, I guess) because it's in limp mode. By far, the most annoying part is the low coolant sensor in the expansion tank. If that tank gets a bit low, it will put you in limp mode even if the truck is running cool as a cucumber. It really sucks if that happens when you're near the top of a mountain pass and have to stop, still hanging half way out in the right lane.

Ever since that incident, I bypass the low coolant sensor on every one that I drive.
 

77Dmax

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2024
Posts
129
Reaction score
243
Location
vt
First Name
Joe
Truck Year
1977
Truck Model
c20
Engine Size
6.6
The duramax will have better resale value. Folks are all over the older diesels. The 8.1s are beasts, but will always use way more fuel getting the same job done.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
45,140
Posts
976,092
Members
38,098
Latest member
muno
Top