That sucks... exactly what my statement regarding Dman or used parts...
So many engines get pulled and dropped on the crank and balancer, if the engines was hit in an accident or pulled and dropped on the ground, the bottom pulleys get bent.
The stuff from Dman has been bad, even though it's brand new...
Do you have a bad bearing in you alternator? The shaft play should be minimal...
I have had to throw away an aftermarket alternator which was rebuilt with crap bearings...
My new alt was $360.00 made in USA.
Is there damge to your ring gear or flywheel and did you buy the correct balancer?
My 1987 and 1994 engine's are internally balanced, use a neutral snout balancer and externally balanced on the ring gear...
1986 and earlier, which came with carburators and old pattern head bolts are External ballanced with a different snout balancer... If you look inside the 86 and older balancer's, there's a chunk of steel behind the rubber or steel ring, with the timing marks... If it is not there, you found your issue...
The 87' and newer balancer's will NOT have the steel chunk behind the rubber/steel outer chunk with timing notches.
They will have anywhere from 3-7 drilled 3/8" holes into the rubber/steel, where they were balanced by the manufacturer. Usually behind the back side...
That said, my research on crap aftermarket parts, taught me to by genuine GM Balancer or the $380-$460 race version and nothing in between...
Not one aftermarket balancer company's parts were found within tolerance... at 6K RPM...
This is why you'll find my posts very demanding regarding where you source parts and what you bolt on... Strict
When I asked for a Long Water Pump, and provide a Chevrolet Performance number, so I knew it was correct rotation and the same one installed in the 355HO or Stage 4 and stage 6 TPI GM Performance engines, my local parts store told me off and said, "You'll use what I sell you, off the shelf"...
I tried to pay $150.00 and he insisted I use the cheap $75.00 unit or the $35.00 unit he bought from China aftermarket with substandard bearings... so I had to buy online...
My point is: Every part you select, may cause additional issues...
I have 4 brand new bad from the seller ignition modules...
Bad Lifters, brand new with poor machining, Bad timing set, with sub standard cheapo chain on poor cast iron gears... (from a previously good brand name) Brand new wires, which cause bad timing... (Same store as the pump)...
Pardon me for sounding so pushy, when I make remarks... It's for the best or you'll have a bunch of worthless crap on your shelf as well.
The only thing worse, is somebody learning the hard way what is poor quality, and then find them selling known bad parts to others... so they can get their money back... Ruthless... in my opinion.
Stay alert... add some pics of your balancer... verify your ring gear is not bad / aka missing teeth, cracked or the weight flew off, if you have one... It can happen... and double check your alignment of your belts... Aftermarket ring gears have ruined engines...
You may need a shim somewhere...
If you zoom in on the pictures I showed you, you'll see 1 washer is stacked against the engine spacer at the block and at the alternator bracket pivot... and 2 behind the pivot nut... It must be very well aligned... or you'll eat a belt... vibrate...
The last thing it could be is the centrifugal clutch weights on the A/C or a bad converter bearing / pump bearing at the trans... Bad water pump bearing... bent fan or broken clutch on the fan...
I have seen the fan swapped out and the wrong rotation reverse fan put on the wrong direction assembly as well. The fan will be running backwards if somebody pulled one from a serpentine system. I had a parts store sell me the wrong rotation fan for my serpentine 4.3L...
Same will happen at the water pump... wrong junk yard parts will blow your build. Reverse rotation fan will come through your hood, when it breaks... scare the heck outta yah... NO BS. Could kill someone.
Just keep saying to your self: "Everything Matters, All the Time..."
You'll find it, just hang in there... add some pics...
Do not drive it with a balance issue. You'll break something else...
A worn idler bearing on a serpentine system eats the rear tail shaft bearing at the transmission... believe it or NOT...